Menu

The 16 Best Chicago-Style Pizza in Sydney

For pizza enthusiasts in Sydney looking to indulge in the iconic Chicago-style pizza, the search for the perfect spot can sometimes feel overwhelming. With so many options to choose from, finding the best place to satisfy your deep-dish cravings can be a daunting task.

Fortunately, this page is dedicated to helping you navigate the world of Chicago-style pizza in Sydney by compiling a list of the top contenders in the city. Whether you prefer a classic cheese-filled pie or a unique twist on the traditional recipe, you'll find a variety of options to suit your taste buds.

Explore these top picks and more to find the best Chicago-style pizza in Sydney that will leave you coming back for more.

How we built this ranking

To put together this guide to Chicago-Style pizza in Sydney, we looked at what each business really focuses on, how its customers rate it over time and what it shows about its work on its own channels. The order is ours and we review it regularly.

No business can pay to be included. Those already in the guide may buy extra visibility, and it is always shown.

Top 3The full listMapPicking the right one

Our top picks

Choose a business to go straight to its entry.

#1
Papa Pizza
4.6182 reviews
#2
Messina Pizza and Pasta
4.6138 reviews
#3
Antico Woodfired Pizza
4.5840 reviews

Compare 16 options nearby

Papa Pizza, Sydney#1
Strong points

  • Amazing service with complimentary garlic pizza and chocolate mousse.

  • Fantastic quality and value for made-to-order pizzas.

  • Family-friendly atmosphere with great portions at affordable prices.

  • Fast and friendly service even during busy times like New Year's Eve.

Papa Pizza

4.6182 reviews
509 Old South Head Rd, Rose Bay NSW 2029, Australia

Papa Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant in Rose Bay, Australia. They offer a variety of services including outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The establishment also provides amenities like toilets and is wheelchair-accessible.

Customers rave about Papa Pizza, with a rating of 4.6 stars. Some key points from reviews include:

Messina Pizza and Pasta, Sydney#2
Strong points

  • Bad food, slow delivery, and disappointing service. Staff was rude and the pizza was subpar.

  • Great food, especially the fettuccini boscaiola. Friendly service and consistent quality.

  • Highly recommended for delicious pizza and excellent customer service. A local favorite for pizza delivery.

  • Delicious pizza and fresh ingredients, accommodating for allergies. Inconsistent pricing for delivery orders.

Messina Pizza and Pasta

4.6138 reviews
3/518 George St, South Windsor NSW 2756, Australia

Messina Pizza and Pasta is a popular pizza restaurant located in South Windsor, Australia. They offer a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. The restaurant is known for its fast service and casual atmosphere.

One of the standout dishes mentioned in customer reviews is the Fettuccini boscaiola, described as the best take away pasta available. Customers have also praised the friendly service and the quality of food at Messina Pizza and Pasta.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Overall, customers appreciate the quality of food, friendly service, and the convenience of ordering from Messina Pizza and Pasta. If you're looking for a tasty pizza or pasta dish, this restaurant is worth a visit.

Antico Woodfired Pizza, Sydney#3
Strong points

  • Great woodfired pizza and pasta servings are generous.

  • Easy reservation process with good options for vegetarians.

  • Outstanding customer service and large portion sizes with delicious food.

  • Professional and friendly staff, offering high-quality wood-fired pizza.

Antico Woodfired Pizza

4.5840 reviews
2A Sharman Cl, Harrington Park NSW 2567, Australia

Antico Woodfired Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in Harrington Park, NSW. The establishment offers a range of services and features to cater to its customers, including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. One of the highlights of the restaurant is the presence of a fireplace, adding to its cozy atmosphere. Accessibility is also a priority, with wheelchair-accessible facilities available.

Customers have left 840 reviews for Antico Woodfired Pizza, resulting in an impressive rating of 4.5 stars. Let's summarize a few key points from these reviews:

So, whether you're craving a delicious pizza, looking for a cozy dining experience, or seeking outstanding customer service, Antico Woodfired Pizza has you covered!

Rosso Antico Pizza Bar, Sydney#4
Strong points

  • The crust on the pizzas is sensational, perfect for bread lovers.

  • Vegetarian-friendly options are available, catering to diverse preferences.

  • Great service and atmosphere, with generous serving sizes.

  • High-quality ingredients and mind-blowing specials that stand out.

Rosso Antico Pizza Bar

4.5741 reviews
2/52-60 Enmore Rd, Newtown NSW 2042, Australia

Rosso Antico Pizza Bar is a renowned establishment in Newtown, Australia, offering a delightful experience for pizza enthusiasts. With a remarkable rating of 4.5 stars, this pizza restaurant has garnered 741 reviews from satisfied customers.

Customers rave about the quality of the dough and the ample vegetarian selections. Some customers appreciate the generous serving sizes, while others praise the exceptional service and authentic Italian flavors. The ambiance at Rosso Antico Pizza Bar is highlighted as casual and cozy, creating a welcoming environment for diners. Visit their website for more information and indulge in some of the best pizzas in Sydney!

La Pizza Bella, Sydney#5
Strong points

  • Love the hell chicken pizza & spicy wings, mouthwatering! Friendly service, great location only a short walk from Surry Hills.

  • Delicious large slice pizzas. The Funghi was tasty and a bit crispy on the crust.

  • Pepperoni was too salty, but BBQ Chicken had better flavor. Pizzas are precooked and reheated, which affected the cheese texture.

  • I love the variety of ingredients, thin pizza crust, and barbecue ribs. Highly recommended!

La Pizza Bella

4.5516 reviews
310 Crown St, Darlinghurst NSW 2010, Australia

La Pizza Bella is a beloved pizza restaurant located in Darlinghurst, Australia. They offer a variety of dining options including lunch, dinner, catering, and more. Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in services. The restaurant has a casual atmosphere that is family-friendly.

With a rating of 4.5 based on 516 reviews, it's clear that customers love La Pizza Bella. Some key points from customer reviews include:

From the fresh ingredients to the friendly service, La Pizza Bella is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts in the area. Visit their website for more information and to place an order.

Manoosh Pizzeria, Sydney#6
Strong points

  • One customer regretted not going to Maccas instead due to the disappointing pizzas they ordered.

  • Another customer enjoyed the Pepperoni Burst pizza but felt it needed more tomato paste to be perfect.

  • A happy customer praised the vegan cheese option and thin crust of their pizza.

  • Another customer loved the deluxe garlic bread and haloumi cheese pie, highlighting the amazing flavors.

Manoosh Pizzeria

4.5274 reviews
7 Belmore Rd, Randwick NSW 2031, Australia

Manoosh Pizzeria is a popular pizza restaurant in Randwick that offers a variety of services for its customers. Whether you prefer outdoor seating or takeaway, this place has you covered. The restaurant also provides Halal food, vegan options, and vegetarian options for those with dietary preferences.

Customers rave about the delicious pizzas and other dishes available at Manoosh Pizzeria. Some key points from their reviews include:

With a solid rating of 4.5 stars from 274 reviews, Manoosh Pizzeria is definitely a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters, Sydney#7
Strong points

  • The waiters are fantastic, providing quick service and excellent recommendations.

  • The portion sizes are generous, so be prepared for a delightful feast.

  • The food is delicious and iconic, perfect for sharing with a group.

Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters

4.46,161 reviews
Shop 2/338 Pitt St, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia

Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters is a renowned Italian restaurant located in Sydney. They offer a variety of services such as delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Accessibility features include a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating. Customers can enjoy alcohol, including beer and cocktails, as well as coffee and organic dishes. The cozy atmosphere is welcoming for families, groups, and LGBTQ+ individuals.

Customers have praised the friendly and efficient service at Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters. One review highlights the delicious wood-fired pizzas and perfectly cooked pasta dishes, along with a slight disappointment in the Sangria. Another comment raves about the great experience dining at the restaurant, from the amazing food presentation to the friendly staff. Lastly, a review mentions the exceptional pizza quality and variety, although caution is advised regarding the beer prices. Overall, the restaurant promises a gastronomic experience worth revisiting.

The Pizza & Pasta Kitchen, Sydney#8
Strong points

  • Great range of vegan choices with friendly service

  • Generous portions and quick service

  • Ambiance is inviting with ample seating

  • Excellent food quality and caring service

The Pizza & Pasta Kitchen

4.41,117 reviews
Shop 4/4 Claudia Rd, Toongabbie NSW 2146, Australia

The Pizza & Pasta Kitchen is a renowned pizza restaurant in Toongabbie, NSW that offers a variety of services to its customers. With options for outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, this restaurant aims to provide flexibility to meet the diverse needs of its clientele.

Customers have expressed their satisfaction with the wide range of vegan and vegetarian options available on the menu. The friendly staff and quick service have left patrons delighted with their dining experience.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

The Pizza & Pasta Kitchen excels in providing a delightful dining experience with its diverse menu offerings and top-notch customer service. Whether you're looking for vegan options or traditional favorites, this restaurant aims to cater to all tastes.

Zio Pino Pizzeria, Sydney#9
Strong points

  • Great experience with welcoming staff, delicious food, and cozy ambiance.

  • Tasteful, authentic Italian food served by friendly and attentive staff.

  • Reasonably priced, great food, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home.

  • Yummy food with large portions at fair prices in a neat and clean environment.

Zio Pino Pizzeria

4.4647 reviews
930 Botany Rd, Mascot NSW 2020, Australia

Zio Pino Pizzeria is a renowned pizza restaurant located in Mascot, Australia, known for its authentic Italian cuisine and warm atmosphere. The restaurant offers a range of services such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers appreciate the no-contact delivery service and the wheelchair-accessible facilities.

Some key reviews from satisfied patrons include:

With a high rating of 4.4, Zio Pino Pizzeria continues to impress customers with its exceptional service and delicious Italian fare. Visit their website to explore their menu and make a reservation for an unforgettable dining experience.

Pizza Inn, Sydney#10
Strong points

  • Fantastic pizza selection

  • Quick and friendly service

  • Cozy atmosphere

Pizza Inn

4.4135 reviews
293 Bexley Rd, Bexley North NSW 2207, Australia

Pizza Inn is a popular pizza restaurant located in Bexley North, Australia. They offer a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. The restaurant is known for its coffee and late-night food offerings, making it a favorite spot for customers looking for a delicious meal at any time of day.

Customers have praised Pizza Inn for several reasons:

Whether you're looking for a place to dine with friends or just craving a late-night snack, Pizza Inn has you covered. With its wheelchair-accessible seating and amenities like toilets, the restaurant strives to provide a comfortable experience for all customers. Make sure to check out their website for more information and menu options!

Las Vegas Pizza Restaurant, Sydney#11
Strong points

  • This restaurant makes the best pizza with high fluffy and crispy bases and generous toppings.

  • Consistent quality and toppings over the years, highly recommended for pizza lovers.

  • Thirty-year-old local pizza shop offering great deals and delicious pizzas, a must-try for Rockdale residents.

  • Amazing pizzas like Capricciosa and Traditional Garlic Crust served in a relaxed and pleasant environment.

Las Vegas Pizza Restaurant

4.4153 reviews
46/46 Bay St, Rockdale NSW 2216, Australia

Las Vegas Pizza Restaurant is a popular Pizza restaurant located in Rockdale, NSW. They offer a variety of service options such as Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. The restaurant is wheelchair-accessible and provides late-night food. Customers can enjoy their meals in a casual atmosphere suitable for groups and children. The restaurant also offers lunch and dinner options and accepts reservations.

Customer reviews highlight the exceptional quality of the pizzas served at Las Vegas Pizza Restaurant. Here are some key points from recent reviews:

Bondi Pizza, Sydney#12
Strong points

  • The Motown BBQ Deep Dish pizza was astonishingly good, with perfect portion sizes and delicious brownies with ice cream.

  • The staff is accommodating and attentive, with fast service and anticipation of customer needs.

  • The Detroit style pizzas are a must-have, full of amazing flavors, and the drinks are great, served quickly even before the food.

  • The thin pizzas, pasta, and salads are consistently delicious, and the serving sizes are adequate for sharing.

Bondi Pizza

4.31,662 reviews
Shops 446 & 447, Level 4, Cnr Herring Rd &, Waterloo Rd, Macquarie Park NSW 2113, Australia

Bondi Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in Macquarie Park, Australia, offering a variety of services to its customers. They provide options such as no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, ensuring there is something for everyone.

One of the highlights of Bondi Pizza is their Great cocktails, which are a hit among customers. The atmosphere is described as casual, perfect for gathering with friends or family. Additionally, they offer a range of dining options including lunch, dinner, catering, dessert, and seating.

Customers have left glowing reviews about their experiences at Bondi Pizza. Some key points from the reviews include:

With a rating of 4.3 out of 5, Bondi Pizza continues to impress its customers with excellent food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Deep Dish Kings, Sydney#13
Strong points

  • Customers love the Chicago-style pizzas for their thickness, cheesiness, and ample toppings.

  • Some reviewers mentioned that while the pizzas may not match the traditional Chicago style to a tee, they are still tasty and satisfying.

  • Delivery service is fast and friendly, ensuring that customers receive their piping hot pizzas promptly.

  • The Cluck Norris pizza and the dessert options like the Banoffee pie have also received high praise from patrons.

Deep Dish Kings

4.334 reviews
45 Kiora Rd, Miranda NSW 2228, Australia

Deep Dish Kings is a renowned establishment offering delightful Chicago-style pizzas that are rich, cheesy, and generously topped. Customers have praised the unique experience of indulging in these thick, flavorful pizzas that stand out from the norm. The menu includes a variety of options, each crafted with care and served with a small cup of honey for that extra touch of sweetness.

MIn the area
#14
Strong points

  • One customer had a disappointing experience with the pizza quality and found it unappetizing.

  • Another customer expressed immense gratitude for the early delivery service provided for a special event.

  • A positive review highlighted the delicious taste of the pizzas, particularly praising the authenticity and flavors.

  • A customer recommended Memo's as the best pizza place in the Granville area, emphasizing the friendly service and affordable prices.

Memo's Pizza, Pasta & Kebab

4.2281 reviews
179 Clyde St, Granville NSW 2142, Australia

Memo's Pizza, Pasta & Kebab is a popular pizza restaurant located in Granville, Australia. They offer a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy healthy options, late-night food, and small plates. The restaurant has a casual atmosphere and is wheelchair-accessible, making it suitable for groups and families with kids.

With a rating of 4.2 based on 281 reviews, Memo's Pizza, Pasta & Kebab has garnered a loyal following. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Whether you're looking for a quick takeaway meal or a casual dining experience, Memo's Pizza, Pasta & Kebab is a top choice for flavorful pizzas and kebabs.

Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra, Sydney#15
Strong points

  • Amazing pizza with generous toppings and thin crispy base

  • Easy ordering process with prompt delivery and delicious hot pizza

  • Great twist on classic pizza flavors with special creations

  • XL pizza size feeds multiple people and offers delicious flavors

Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra

4.1111 reviews
323 Malabar Rd, Maroubra NSW 2035, Australia

Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra is a popular spot for pizza delivery in Maroubra. They offer convenient delivery and takeaway options for their customers. The business accepts debit cards and NFC mobile payments for a hassle-free transaction.

With a solid rating of 4.1, Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra has garnered positive reviews from satisfied customers. Some key points from their reviews include:

Customers praise Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra for their delicious pizzas and efficient service. If you're in the mood for a tasty pizza, Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra is worth a try!

Crust Pizza Concord, Sydney#16
Strong points

  • The customer service and pizza are both good. The pizza at this store is much better than the one at other nearby stores.

  • Love their pizza, customer service is also good. But they should have one pizza storing heater like Dominos so that it’ll be warmer even if it’s ready.

  • There's onion skin on the pizza. I think there's a problem with hygiene. It's getting worse.

Crust Pizza Concord

3.6323 reviews
177 Concord Rd, Concord NSW 2137, Australia

Crust Pizza Concord is a popular pizza restaurant located in Concord, NSW. They offer a variety of service options including no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. The casual atmosphere makes it a great spot for individuals and groups alike. Families with kids will appreciate that it is good for kids and there is free of charge street parking available.

Customers have shared their experiences with Crust Pizza Concord. Some key points from their reviews include:

Overall, Crust Pizza Concord offers a pleasant dining experience with delicious pizza options and friendly service.

A quick comparison of the options

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Papa Pizza 4.6182
#2Messina Pizza and Pasta 4.6138
#3Antico Woodfired Pizza 4.5840
#4Rosso Antico Pizza Bar 4.5741
#5La Pizza Bella 4.5516
#6Manoosh Pizzeria 4.5274
#7Macchiato Wood Fire Pizza and Coffee Roasters 4.46,161
#8The Pizza & Pasta Kitchen 4.41,117
#9Zio Pino Pizzeria 4.4647
#10Pizza Inn 4.4135
#11Las Vegas Pizza Restaurant 4.4153
#12Bondi Pizza 4.31,662
#13Deep Dish Kings 4.334
#14Memo's Pizza, Pasta & Kebab 4.2281
#15Rocketboy Pizza Maroubra 4.1111
#16Crust Pizza Concord 3.6323

Running a local business?

Manage my business profile

Map of Chicago-Style Pizza in Sydney

If you're a fan of Chicago style pizza, then you'll be thrilled to know that there are several delicious options right here in Sydney. From deep dish to stuffed crust, these locations serve up authentic and mouthwatering versions of this iconic dish. Check out the map below to discover all the best places to grab a slice of Chicago style pizza in Sydney. View Ranking

Choosing well among Chicago-Style Pizza in Sydney

  1. Locanto's Deep Dish Pizza - known for their authentic Chicago-style crust.
  2. Giordano's Pizza - offers a range of deep-dish and stuffed pizzas.
  3. Deep Dish Pizza Co.
  4. - specializes in loaded deep-dish pies.
  5. Windy City Pizzeria - a popular spot for those craving a taste of Chicago.

Questions readers ask

What makes Chicago style pizza different from other types?

Chicago style pizza is known for its deep dish crust, which is thick and crunchy on the outside while being soft and doughy on the inside. The toppings are typically layered in reverse order compared to traditional pizza, with cheese placed on the bottom and sauce on top. This creates a deliciously rich and hearty flavor profile that sets it apart from New York or Neapolitan styles. Another key feature of Chicago style pizza is the use of a high edge to form a deep pan, allowing for generous amounts of toppings to be added. This results in a filling and satisfying meal that is perfect for sharing with friends and family. Unlike other types of pizza, Chicago style pizza often requires a longer baking time to fully cook the thick crust and allow the flavors to meld together. This patient approach to pizza-making results in a unique and mouthwatering dining experience that is worth the wait.

Where can I find authentic Chicago style pizza in Sydney?

If you're craving Chicago style pizza in Sydney, there are several restaurants that specialize in serving this delicious dish. From deep dish pies to traditional toppings, these eateries offer a taste of the Windy City right in your own backyard. One popular spot for Chicago style pizza in Sydney is Pizzeria Uno, which is known for its authentic deep dish pies and generous portions. Another standout option is Chi-Town Pizza, where you can customize your own pizza with your favorite toppings and cheeses. For those looking for a more upscale dining experience, Giordano's is a top choice for Chicago style pizza in Sydney. With its gourmet ingredients and unique flavor combinations, this restaurant offers a taste of true Chicago-style cuisine.

What are some popular toppings for Chicago style pizza?

When it comes to Chicago style pizza, there are a variety of popular toppings that complement the rich and hearty flavors of the dish. From classic choices to unique creations, these toppings add a delicious twist to the traditional deep dish pie. Some popular toppings for Chicago style pizza include: Whether you prefer traditional toppings or want to try something new, there are plenty of options to choose from when it comes to Chicago style pizza in Sydney. Sausage: A classic choice that adds a savory and slightly spicy kick to the pie. Pepperoni: A beloved topping that adds a salty and savory flavor to each bite. Mushrooms: A versatile topping that pairs well with the cheese and sauce, creating a deliciously earthy taste. Spinach: A fresh and vibrant topping that adds a pop of color and flavor to the pie.

Is Chicago style pizza suitable for vegetarians or vegans?

While Chicago style pizza is traditionally known for its meaty toppings and gooey cheese, there are plenty of vegetarian and vegan options available for those with dietary restrictions. From plant-based proteins to dairy-free cheeses, these alternatives make it possible for everyone to enjoy this delicious dish. Many restaurants that offer Chicago style pizza in Sydney have vegetarian and vegan menu options, including toppings like: Additionally, some establishments offer dairy-free cheese or vegan cheese as a substitute for traditional mozzarella, allowing those with dairy allergies or dietary preferences to still indulge in the deep dish goodness of Chicago style pizza. Vegetarian sausage or pepperoni. Black olives. Artichoke hearts. Roasted red peppers.

Keep exploring

The 14 Best Casual Dining SydneyThe 15 Best Breakfast Spots in Newtown, SydneyThe 9 Best Colombian Restaurants in Sydney